Let’s be honest—choosing an engagement ring is one of the biggest moments of your life. It’s exciting, nerve-wracking, and yes, a little overwhelming. If you’re stuck between going fully custom or picking up a stunning ready-to-wear ring, you’re not alone. Think of it like choosing between a couture gown and an off-the-rack stunner: both can turn heads, but which one is truly you?

If you’re shopping for custom engagement rings in Denver, or just curious about your options, we’re breaking down everything you need to know to help you decide—without the stress.

What’s a Custom Engagement Ring (and Why It’s Totally Worth It)?

A custom engagement ring is exactly what it sounds like: a completely one-of-a-kind piece designed just for you. From the shape of the center stone to the tiniest details on the band, every element is made to match your unique vision.

The Pros:

• You Do You. Want a marquise diamond with a twisted band in two-tone gold? Go for it. Custom rings let you get exactly what you want, no compromises.
  

• Sentimental Value, Off the Charts. Incorporate heirloom stones, engrave a special date, or design something inspired by where you met. It’s a wearable love story.
  

• Endless Options. Mix gemstones, metals, cuts, and styles. The sky’s the limit.
  
  

The Cons:

• It Takes Time. Expect at least 6–8 weeks from your first design consultation to that magical moment when you slip it on. (But hey, patience is a virtue.)
  

• More Investment. Custom usually means a higher price tag, thanks to all the extra love and labor.
  
  

Why Denver Couples Are Obsessed:

Here in Denver, where artisanal and unique are the vibe, custom engagement rings are seriously popular. At Ashley Schenkein Jewelry Design, our 5-step custom journey is smooth, personal, and totally fun. We’ll brainstorm with you, sketch out ideas, source stones, and craft your dream ring down to the last delicate detail. (Check out our full process here.)

What’s a Ready-to-Wear Engagement Ring?

A ready-to-wear engagement ring is a pre-made piece you can try on, fall in love with, and take home the same day. It’s all about convenience, and trust us, there’s nothing wrong with loving a design that’s already perfect.

The Pros:

• Instant Gratification. No waiting. You see it, you love it, you make it official.
  

• Budget-Friendly. Pricing is clear and predictable, with fewer surprise costs.
  

• Tried & True Designs. Classic shapes and styles that have stood the test of time (because timeless is always in style).
  
  

The Cons:

• Less Unique. While still beautiful, these rings are made in multiples—so you might see the same design out in the wild.
  

• Minimal Customization. You can often resize or swap out a stone, but big changes? Not so much.
  
  

Custom vs. Premade Rings—The Showdown

So, how do these two stack up side by side? Here’s a quick comparison:

Bottom line: Are you a “let’s make magic happen” type, or more of a “love at first sight” kind of shopper?

How to Decide Which Ring Is Right for You

Still on the fence? Here are some fun (but actually helpful) questions to ask yourself:

• Do you have a clear vision for your dream ring—or no clue?

• If you’ve had your Pinterest board planned since 2015, custom might be calling your name. If you're open to falling in love with something unexpected, ready-to-wear could be your match.
  

• What’s your timeline?

• If your proposal plans are fast-approaching, a ready-to-wear ring is your BFF. Got time to spare? Custom’s worth the wait.
  

• How important is uniqueness to you?

• Want to know without a doubt that your ring is one of a kind? Custom’s the answer. But if you’re more into timeless classics, ready-to-wear delivers—beautifully.
  

• What’s your budget?

• Both options offer flexibility, but custom designs typically come with a higher price tag because of the personal touches and craftsmanship involved.
  

• Are you a detail-obsessed person?

• Love being part of the creative process and seeing sketches come to life? Custom is your vibe. Prefer to keep it simple and stress-free? Ready-to-wear keeps things easy-breezy.
  
  

The ASJD Experience

At Ashley Schenkein Jewelry Design, we love helping you celebrate your love story—whether that’s through a one-of-a-kind custom engagement ring in Denver or a jaw-dropping ready-to-wear engagement ring that makes your heart skip a beat. Our team is here to guide you, answer your questions (no judgment, ever), and make sure you walk out feeling 100% confident in your choice.

Need inspo? Our shop is stocked with stunning designs, and our Custom Journey is tailor-made to bring your vision to life. We’re here for all of it—your “OMG yes!” moments and everything in between.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, whether you say “I do” with a custom engagement ring or a ready-to-wear stunner, the most important thing is that your ring feels right for you. It’s not about following trends or ticking boxes—it’s about wearing a piece that makes you smile every time you catch a glimpse of it.

So what’s it going to be: bespoke brilliance or instant sparkle? Either way, we’ve got your back (and your ring finger).

✨ Ready to start your journey? Visit us in Denver to explore our collection or chat with us about creating something custom just for you. Your dream ring is waiting.