Skip to content

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $100 & FREE RETURNS* DETAILS

  • Custom Experience
    • Schedule Custom Consultation
    • Ultimate Ring Guide
    • The Custom Journey
    • Custom Jewelry Gallery
    • Why Ashley Schenkein Jewelry Design
    • Heirloom Redesign
    • Testimonials
    • Education
      • The 4 C's
      • Diamond Shapes
      • Types of Metals
      • Types of Stones
    • Preparing for your consultation
    • Loose Diamonds
  • Permanent Jewelry
    • Book an Appointment
    • The Process
    • Permanent Jewelry FAQs
    • Chain and Charm Options
    • Permanent Jewelry Events
  • Engagement & Wedding Bands
    • Custom Jewelry Gallery
    • Engagement Rings
    • Diamond Bands
    • Metal Bands
    • Tracer Bands and Ring Guards
  • Shop Collections
    • Kyoto Edit Collection
    • Mexico City Collection
    • Melrose Collection
    • Silver & Vermeil Diamonds Collection
      • Earrings
      • Necklaces
    • 14k Fine Jewelry Collection
      • Earrings
      • Necklaces
      • Rings
      • Bracelets
    • Personalized Collection
  • Shop Categories
    • Best Sellers
    • New Arrivals
    • Everyday Quiet Luxury
    • Earrings
      • Stud Earrings
      • Single Stud Earrings
      • Dangle and Drop Earrings
      • Hoops and Huggies
      • 14k Fine Earrings
    • Necklaces
      • Short Necklaces
      • Chain Necklaces
      • 14k Fine Necklaces
    • Rings
      • CZ Rings
      • Stacking Rings
      • Gemstone Rings
      • 18k Vermeil Rings
      • Gold-Filled Rings
      • 14k Solid Gold Rings
    • Bracelets
    • Gold-Filled
    • Sale
    • Travel and Home
    • Gift Cards
  • About
    • Ashley's Journey
    • Events
    • Contact Us
    • Giving Back
    • FAQs
    • Wholesale
    • Ultimate Ring Guide
    • Our Values & Promises
Log in
No account yet? Create Account
    Search

    Search

    logo
    Search

    Search

    Log in Create Account
    00 items
    • Custom Experience
      • Schedule Custom Consultation
      • Ultimate Ring Guide
      • The Custom Journey
      • Custom Jewelry Gallery
      • Why Ashley Schenkein Jewelry Design
      • Heirloom Redesign
      • Testimonials
      • Education
        • The 4 C's
        • Diamond Shapes
        • Types of Metals
        • Types of Stones
      • Preparing for your consultation
      • Loose Diamonds
    • Permanent Jewelry
      • Book an Appointment
      • The Process
      • Permanent Jewelry FAQs
      • Chain and Charm Options
      • Permanent Jewelry Events
    • Engagement & Wedding Bands
      • Custom Jewelry Gallery
      • Engagement Rings
      • Diamond Bands
      • Metal Bands
      • Tracer Bands and Ring Guards
    • Shop Collections
      • Kyoto Edit Collection
      • Mexico City Collection
      • Melrose Collection
      • Silver & Vermeil Diamonds Collection
        • Earrings
        • Necklaces
      • 14k Fine Jewelry Collection
        • Earrings
        • Necklaces
        • Rings
        • Bracelets
      • Personalized Collection
    • Shop Categories
      • Best Sellers
      • New Arrivals
      • Everyday Quiet Luxury
      • Earrings
        • Stud Earrings
        • Single Stud Earrings
        • Dangle and Drop Earrings
        • Hoops and Huggies
        • 14k Fine Earrings
      • Necklaces
        • Short Necklaces
        • Chain Necklaces
        • 14k Fine Necklaces
      • Rings
        • CZ Rings
        • Stacking Rings
        • Gemstone Rings
        • 18k Vermeil Rings
        • Gold-Filled Rings
        • 14k Solid Gold Rings
      • Bracelets
      • Gold-Filled
      • Sale
      • Travel and Home
      • Gift Cards
    • About
      • Ashley's Journey
      • Events
      • Contact Us
      • Giving Back
      • FAQs
      • Wholesale
      • Ultimate Ring Guide
      • Our Values & Promises

    Blog Detail

    9 Online Jewelry Shopping Mistakes to Steer Clear Of
    Updated on  July 23, 2024 by  Coco T.

    9 Online Jewelry Shopping Mistakes to Steer Clear Of

    Shopping for jewelry online can feel like navigating a dazzling but treacherous diamond mine. With so many glittering options at your fingertips, it's easy to get lured in by a seemingly perfect piece, only to end up with a dud that looks nothing like the picture. But fear not, dears! By steering clear of these 9 common online jewelry shopping mistakes, you'll be rocking your new bling with confidence in no time. Get ready to shop smarter, not harder, and add some serious sparkle to your collection without any fashion faux pas.


    Mistake #1: Not Checking the Return Policy
    Before hitting that "add to cart" button, make sure you've thoroughly investigated the seller's return policy. Because let's face it, sometimes that statement necklace that looked stunning on screen ends up being a tacky tangle of disappointment in real life. Don't get stuck with a piece you can't return. Look for sellers with generous, no-hassle return policies to send back any items that don't meet your expectations. That way, you can shop with peace of mind knowing that if your new earrings aren't as dazzling as described, you can easily exchange them or get your money back. Life's too short to settle for subpar jewelry, so always check that return policy before taking the plunge.


    Mistake #2: Ignoring Customer Reviews
    In the wild west of online jewelry shopping, customer reviews are your trusty compass. Don't make the mistake of ignoring this valuable resource! Take the time to read through reviews from previous buyers to get a sense of the quality, craftsmanship, and customer service you can expect. If a seller has a slew of 1-star reviews complaining of shoddy workmanship, missing stones, or unresponsive customer support, consider that a giant red flag waving you away. On the flip side, glowing reviews praising the stunning pieces, excellent communication, and speedy shipping are a green light that you've found a gem of a seller. By letting other customers' experiences guide your choices, you'll be well on your way to a jewelry box full of treasures, not trinkets.

    Mistake #3: Not Understanding Metals and Materials
    One of the biggest blunders you can make when buying jewelry online is not educating yourself about the metals and materials used. Not all that glitters is gold, and not every clear stone is a genuine diamond. Before clicking "buy," make sure you understand exactly what you're getting. Is that gleaming band made of solid 14k gold, or is it just gold-plated brass? Are those sparklers real diamonds, or convincing cubic zirconia? Reputable sellers will clearly list the materials used in each piece, so take the time to read the descriptions carefully. If you're unsure about something, don't hesitate to reach out to the seller for clarification. By arming yourself with knowledge about metals and materials, you'll avoid the disappointment of receiving a piece that's not quite what you expected.

    Mistake #4: Skimping on Size and Fit
    When it comes to online jewelry shopping, size really does matter. Don't make the rookie mistake of guessing your ring size or assuming that "one size fits all" necklace will drape perfectly. Take the time to measure your fingers, wrists, and neck to ensure you're ordering the right size. Many sellers provide sizing charts or guides to help you find your perfect fit, so take advantage of these resources. Even better is when there are photos of the jewelry on a model so you can assess the scale of the jewelry. And if you're between sizes or unsure, it's always better to size up rather than down. After all, it's much easier to get a too-big ring resized than to try and squeeze your finger into a too-small one. By paying attention to size and fit, you'll avoid the frustration of ill-fitting pieces and ensure your new jewelry is comfortable and flattering.

    Mistake #5: Falling for Unrealistic Prices
    If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Don't fall for unrealistically low prices on high-end jewelry. That "genuine diamond" tennis bracelet selling for a mere $50? Chances are, those stones are about as authentic as a reality TV show. When shopping for fine jewelry online, be prepared to invest in quality. Look for sellers who offer fair, competitive prices backed by certifications and appraisals. Remember, you're not just buying a pretty bauble, you're investing in a piece that will last a lifetime. Don't let a too-good-to-be-true price tag fool you into sacrificing quality.

    Mistake #6: Not Considering Your Personal Style
    One of the most common mistakes online jewelry shoppers make is getting swept up in trends and forgetting to consider their own personal style. Just because that chunky turquoise necklace looks amazing on the model doesn't mean it'll jive with your minimalist wardrobe. Before hitting "buy," take a moment to think about how the piece will fit into your existing collection and complement your fashion sense. Will you actually wear those oversized hoop earrings, or will they end up gathering dust in your jewelry box? By staying true to your unique style, you'll curate a collection of pieces you'll treasure for years.

    Mistake #7: Skipping the Fine Print
    In the excitement of finding the perfect piece, it's easy to overlook the fine print. But skipping over those details can lead to some unpleasant surprises down the line. Before completing your purchase, take a few minutes to read through the seller's shipping, handling, and insurance policies. Will your new bracelet be covered if it gets lost or damaged in transit? How long will it take to arrive, and will you be able to track the package? By familiarizing yourself with these key details, you'll avoid any unexpected snags and ensure a smooth, stress-free online jewelry shopping experience.

    Mistake #8: Not Asking for Additional Photos or Videos
    One picture may be worth a thousand words, but when it comes to online jewelry shopping, the more visual information you have, the better. Don't hesitate to ask the seller for additional photos or even videos of the piece you're interested in. A reputable seller will be happy to provide you with close-up shots, different angles, and even videos showcasing how the jewelry looks in motion. This extra visual info can give you a much clearer idea of the piece's quality, craftsmanship, and overall appearance. After all, you wouldn't buy a car without taking a test drive, so why purchase a significant piece of jewelry without seeing it from every angle? By requesting more photos or videos, you'll be able to make a more informed decision and avoid any disappointing surprises when your new treasure arrives.

    Mistake #9: Forgetting to Insure Your Purchase
    You've done your research, read the reviews, and finally pulled the trigger on that gorgeous diamond bracelet. But wait! Before you sit back and eagerly await your new arrival, don't forget to insure your purchase. Even with the most reliable sellers and secure shipping methods, there's always a small chance that something could go wrong. By opting for insurance on your online jewelry purchases, you'll protect yourself against loss, theft, or damage during shipping. Most reputable sellers offer insurance options at checkout, and the small added cost is well worth the peace of mind. In the unlikely event that your new bling goes missing or arrives damaged, you'll be covered and able to get a replacement or refund. So, as you're finalizing your purchase, don't overlook that little insurance checkbox. Your future self (and your jewelry collection) will thank you.

    Shopping for jewelry online can be a glittering adventure, but it's not without its pitfalls. By steering clear of these 9 common mistakes - from ignoring customer reviews to skipping insurance - you'll be well on your way to building a stunning collection of pieces you'll cherish. Remember to do your research, ask for additional photos, and always protect your purchases. With these tips in mind, you're ready to dive into the dazzling world of online jewelry shopping with confidence. So go ahead, treat yourself to that statement necklace or those chic stud earrings. Just be sure to shop smart, and shine on!

    RECENT DIARIES

    5 Engagement Ring Settings That Denver Brides Are Loving Right Now
    June 13, 2025 Coco T.

    5 Engagement Ring Settings That Denver Brides Are Loving Right Now

    Picking the diamond? Tough. Picking the setting? Even tougher. But don’t worry—Denver brides are making the choice a whole lot easier in 2025 with ring settings that are equal parts...

    Keep reading
    How to Choose the Right Metal for Your Engagement Ring – According to Denver Jewelers
    June 11, 2025 Coco T.

    How to Choose the Right Metal for Your Engagement Ring – According to Denver Jewelers

    When it comes to engagement rings, everyone talks about the stone—but here’s a secret: the metal is just as important. Think of it as the foundation of your dream home—it...

    Keep reading
    Denver’s Best Proposal Spots: Spring Edition
    June 09, 2025 Coco T.

    Denver’s Best Proposal Spots: Spring Edition

    Spring is in the air—and so is love. If you’re dreaming of a magical, sun-kissed proposal in the heart of the Rockies, we’ve got you covered. Denver is packed with...

    Keep reading
    • Our Values & Promises
    • Returns
    • Repairs
    • Giving Back
    • Events
    • Gift Cards
    • Blog
    • Schedule Custom Consultation
    • Permanent Jewelry Booking
    • Custom Jewelry Gallery
    • Shipping & Terms
    • Contact us

    Find Us

    86 N Pennsylvania Street Denver, CO 80203

    Get In Touch

    hello@asjewelrydesign.com
    720.663.0663

    GET INSIDER ACCESS

    Sign up to be the first to know about exclusive offers, new arrivals, and more.

    © 2024 Ashley Schenkein Jewelry Design

    • Amazon
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Visa

    Cart

    0 items

    Your Cart is Empty

    Loading...

    Shop Now
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.